Some rules for posting/rating decks.

[Dosu Kinuta]

Lately because of the release and everybody getting new cards at the same time, many people have posted there books waited for a responce and no one has responded. To resolve this I believe that there should be some kind of rule for right now on how people post and rate. One simple rule is all I want people to follow. When you post your book try to rate/make suggestions on at least 5 other peoples books to ensure everyone gets atleast some reviews. I'm not saying it has to be long or detailed just what you think about it and what would make it better. And to all you who care about this thank you for your time and cooperation.

[Hatake Kakashi]

Not a bad idea...I personally like to give suggestions to any deck I can.

[VermilionOne]

You can ask that of yourself, and suggest it to others, but you cannot make it a rule.

[Stegy]

Have you seen most of the posts?

"nice dek 9.7/10 i liek it"

That's not helpful at all--all it does is give the poster +1 to his/her post count. I'd rather have 2 good replies then 10 replies like my example.

[nara-shikamaru]

lol, people trying to talk down mods, hilarious.:p

anyways, this isnt zatxhbell, or whatever that is, its a deck!
and furthermore, v1 is correct, no one is allowed to enact rules that werent given the privelege, dosu should just reowrd his statement

but i confess i know the feeling, although understandable as most everyones decks are going to end up roughly the same due to the limited cards, its the odd decks that are getting attention because they arent following the standard.

[Jyoushiro]

Have you seen most of the posts?
"nice dek 9.7/10 i liek it"


That's not helpful at all--all it does is give the poster +1 to his/her post count. I'd rather have 2 good replies then 10 replies like my example.
Quoted for truthery.

[KamigawaChampion]

I'm on the side of VOne in this little discussion. Clearly, people tend to leave small posts with regards to decks in general. Unless it's something unusal, in which case it generates a larger number of posts. We can't force a set of rules when it comes to peoples opinions. However, we can always ignore those posts to begin with. I would hate to see a "flame war" (insults back and forth) started over card choices...or for any reason for that matter.

Well, there's my two cents in this matter. Feel free to agree/disagree with my opinion.

KamigawaChampion